Post Archive
› October 7, 2005
Noguchi Tag Bar?
I was fascinated by this page describing a Noguchi Filing System (via Todd). It's interesting because getting the most out of it is almost unavoidable. Through use it naturally evolves into something more and more convenient. Read the linked page for more details, but the 5 second summary is: don't group files together, instead, package them, label them, and put on a shelf. Move files to the left side of the shelf after use. Repeat, repeat, repeat - eventually your shelf contains most frequently needed documents on the left. It's a frequency-of-use sorting system.
Might this not be a nice implementation for tag based navigation? Rather than the visually weighted and alphabetically sorted tag cloud, how about a list of tags in order of "most clicked". Or actually do the sorting every time you click an item - although that might need to be limited to individual users.
I think a nice implementation of this might show an alphabetical listing, then upon clicking an item, an "alias" of the item is entered into a separate area above the alphabetical list. The alias area would work Noguchi style, shifting the most recently clicked item up top, but the alpha list would remain below. In my illustration here, the Noguchi area has a dark red background, it would constantly shift to show the most recently clicked item up top (probably most recent that *you clicked* only). Perhaps it would be limited to a certain number of links so that infrequently clicked links would not persist.
So anyway I thought I'd share this since it's been floating in my brain and I unfortunately don't have the time to pursue it, but maybe someone else does. Or maybe this is completely unintelligible, I can't yet tell.
Comments
1. October 8, 2005 01:06 AM
2. October 8, 2005 01:26 PM
Marty Posted…
Reminds me of the frequently used programs listing in the WinXP Start Menu. Only run apps are displayed with the more frequently used programs rising to the top.
3. October 8, 2005 02:24 PM
Nels Posted…
I've been wishing that del.icio.us would do this for a while. I think Spurl or Furl does something like that where it shows the most-frequently clicked links... but displaying most frequently clicked tags would be great too.
4. October 8, 2005 05:15 PM
Nate Posted…
Yeah a lot of OS X apps have "Open Recent" menus that list the 8 or so most recently opened files in that app, and of course the OS X finder has "Recent Folders" under the "Go" menu. I think these, and the Windows recent apps (and there's a recent docs too right?) are all very helpful tools, so why not apply them to tag list navigation?
I wonder though, would it really be useful to have this as a communal type feature where the collected most-clicked items are up top, or is this better suited for a per-user type function? For example I think this would be best suited for sites that you log-into, like del.icio.us or flickr, so the frequently clicked list is based only on your own behavior.
.
George Posted…
I was just as intrigued by the system when I saw it pop up on Todd's site. In fact, I had stashed it away in my odd email filing system to consider later on. So in your illustration the section in white would be considered the "holy" section?
I do think you may be on to something since this system would allow you to use it as both a means to tag information all the while seeing their popularity weighting. It would seem to do all this while not being overly complicated.