Post Archive

› April 23, 2002

Aqua Under Inspection

  • Reported by Nate

You may already know that I’m a wanna be mac head, but I strongly believe in scouring information from those who hold opposing viewpoints. These links are regarding the aqua interface in particular:
The Cranky User: Drowning in Aqua (via tremendo)

Top 10 Reasons the Apple Dock Sucks (why the heck is a professional like TOG referencing a graphic right off of the apple servers? that's not cool! Apple seems to have wisely removed the graphic)

Reader responses to Tog's article (favorite quote: “I just read your article about why the Dock sucks. I agree with most of your points. And none of them matter.”)

Eloquently titled article Mac OSX Still Sucks

A set of suggestions based on initial release of aqua, and proof that apple takes customer feedback seriously.

The Interface Mafia’s Redesigning the OS X Dock

And there is so much more, feel free to add your favorites in comments. I should also probably note that the links above are not very timely, and I don’t yet have the pleasure of owning a mac with osx (one day i hope!).

Comments

1. April 23, 2002 12:36 PM

Quote this comment

AndyEd Posted…

While the dock certainly has it’s problems, there’s a nugget of true interaction genius in there. The expansion of targets as the mouse gets near them has been empirically proven to boost mouse movement times very significantly, shaving up to .5sec off a 2 second mouse move with the expansion occurring as far as 75% into a 600px’ish mouse move. The url above offers more info.

2. April 23, 2002 01:26 PM

Quote this comment

evan Posted…

Now would be a good time to remention my Mac/OS X Blog where I discuss software, complain about my transition to the new system , and link to and complain about articles such as these. OS X does indeed kick ass, especially for this reformed Windows user, but it seems as though every single article I’ve read criticizing the new interface, the dock and the lack of “x” has been written by a user with a strong Apple/neXt background who is just experiencing change and considers that change to be a bad thing (my notes here and here). Any users tranisitioning from Windows or Linux out there that can share their experience and feelings about the new OS?

3. April 23, 2002 02:06 PM

Quote this comment

evan Posted…

The reader feedback from the “Mac OS X Still Sucks” linked to above includes many examples pointing out the criticism I mentioned in my previous post – and is pretty funny to boot. Mac heads are a pretty hard–core bunch ;)